• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Elizabeth Minchilli

  • About
  • Week in Italy Food Tours
  • Day Food Tours
  • Books
  • Restaurants
  • Recipes
  • Press
  • Signup
  • Nav Social Menu

    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

new potatoes + anchovies {salad}

May 26, 2014 by Elizabeth 5 Comments

Potates and Anchovies
There’s nothing like writing a book and having it edited to make you realize just how inconsistent and self contradicting you are. While I know I make mistakes with grammar and spelling whenever I put thought to paper, I hadn’t realized that I was making much bigger errors until I got back my marked up manuscript.

Yes, I was saying one thing on page 25 while saying the complete opposite on page 246.

Luckily I have an expert editor who catches these types of things. Also? Thankfully I’m not writing about earth shattering events like World War II or the invention of electricity. No, I’m just musing on life here in Rome, and how I eat and cook my way around it. So the comments from my editor tend to run like this: You said on page 35 that your favorite gelato in Rome is pistachio at Gelateria Pica, then on page 167 you say your favorite is roasted chestnut at Gracchi. Which one?

Can’t a girl have two (or four) favorites when it comes to gelato?

But the whole process has made me think out my definitive declarations more carefully. Like maybe I shouldn’t use the word favorite so liberally? Or declare that I ‘always’ use something, when my ‘always’ can change from one moment to the next (which pretty much defeats the use of the word always.)

One of the aforementioned marked up passages involved the use of anchovies. I love anchovies and use them a lot. But I guess, over the years, I’ve declared the following:

I always use anchovies packed in salt, they are the best.

I always use anchovies packed in olive oil, they are the best.

Again, sorry. But, well, I really did feel that way at the moment. And if I had to pick one type of anchovy over the other, I’m not sure I could. Both are good and both have their merits.

Which kind I use pretty much depends on which ones end up in my kitchen. More often than not my lazy wins out and when I go to grab a jar of anchovies in the store, I’m more likely to go for the olive oil packed because they are easier. Open up the jar and out comes a plump fillet, ready to use

Most recently, when I wrote about making pasta with anchovies I loudly declared my love of anchovies packed in olive oil.  Specifically I said (and I quote myself): Big fat anchovies packed in oil are my favorite.

At which point my friend Beatrice wrote me asking what I had against anchovies preserved in salt. I explained that I didn’t have anything against the salt packed fish, but that I just didn’t happen to have any of them at the time I made dinner. Plus? They are a bit more work.

Beatrice’s response was to immediately send me two jars of what she says are the best salt-packed anchovies ever. (Did I mention that Beatrice has a company that imports Italian food from Italy and distributes them in the USA? And did I mention that one of the things she imports are salt-packed anchovies?)

I have to admit, it took me a few weeks to crack open the jar. And this is where my lazy kicked in. Salt packed anchovies are a bit more work

These anchovies come from the small village of Cetara, on the Amalfi coast. Immediately after being caught, the anchovies are beheaded, and then quickly packed tightly into jars full of salt: bones and all. The fact that they are processed so quickly means that these are some of the tastiest anchovies you can get. But there’s that whole bone and salt thing to get through before you can use them.

Before you use them, the  fish must first be rinsed off, since they are encrusted with the salt and have been soaking in brine. I usually also let them soak in water for about a half hour to make sure I rid them of as much salt as possible. Then, taking a sharp knife, I slice open the belly and flip the anchovy open. If there are any visible innards I pick those out.

And now comes the delicate, tricky part. I gently pull off the spine, along with the bones, being as careful as possible not to pull away any of the precious flesh. They are then ready to go.

As I’ve said in the past, anchovies can make anything good even better. I use them in pasta sauces all the time, and even add them to soups to add that extra umpf of umami. But since I’d gone to all the trouble to filet these babies, I wanted to make something where they wouldn’t disappear and melt into nothing.

New potatoes were quickly steamed, and then tossed with olive oil, the anchovies and a big bunch of arugula.

The anchovies stayed firm and their fishy saltiness was the perfect pairing with this simple, starchy salad.

I hope you’re reading this Beatrice. As you can see, when it comes to anchovies I’m pretty much an equal opportunity employer. Even if it is a bit more work.

PotatoesAnchoviesAnchoviesAnchoviesAnchoviesArugula

Potates and Anchovies
Print

new potatoes + anchovies {salad}

Prep 1 hour

Cook 20 mins

Total 1 hour, 20 mins

Author Elizabeth

Yield 2 -4

Ingredients

  • 1 pound new potatoes
  • 6 anchovies packed in salt
  • 1 big bunch of arugula or watercress, rinsed and chopped
  • 1/2 cup olive oil
  • pepper

Instructions

  1. To prepare the anchovies rinse them off in water. Place in a small bowl and cover with cool water. Let sit for at least a half hour or more.
  2. Rinse and dry the anchovies and place on a wooden board. With a sharp knife, gently slit open the belly, from tail to head (which isn’t there actually). Using your fingers, gently flip the anchovy open. The back bone should stick to one side.
  3. Using your fingers, gently pull up the back bone, starting at one end. Try not to pull up any of the flesh. It’s a bit tricky.
  4. Chop the fillets into 1/4 inch pieces and place in the olive oil in a small bowl.
  5. Scrub the potatoes, but don’t peel. If they are small, leave them whole, otherwise cut them in half. Place them in a steamer and cook until just done. This should only take 10 to 12 minutes.
  6. When the potatoes are done ( you want them cooked, but still firm) place in a bowl. Pour over the olive oil and anchovies and toss. While still warm, add the arugula, and toss. The warmth of the potatoes should wilt the greens. Season with freshly ground black pepper. Serve at room temperature.

Notes

Of course, you could use anchovies packed in oil too. But if you decide to use those packed in oil, and end up cleaning too many at once, you can always store them in a small glass bowl, filled with olive oil. That way you will always have some handy.

 

Potatoes and Anchovies

The anchovies that I used in this recipe were given to me by Gustiamo.

And my pretty little serving dish is from Sberna in Deruta.

Recipes, Salads, Side Dishes, Vegetable salad, vegetable

Share this Post

Join me on Substack!

Sign Up!

Related Posts

VIA ROSA: Our New Tour Company
pasta e ceci
Pumpkin Flan
Tomatoes + Bread
Where to Eat in Puglia
Sformatini di Zucchini
Vegetable Tart with Burrata
Tramezzini for A Cocktail Party
Asparagus + Avocado Bruschetta
Carciofi Pari – Stewed Artichokes
Previous Post: « fish market video {bari}
Next Post: buvette {nyc} »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Engred

    May 26, 2014 at 6:30 pm

    Lovely recipe! I hope you make it down to Cetara while you are visiting the AC!

    Reply
  2. James Daughan

    May 26, 2014 at 6:39 pm

    You got me with “umami.” It’s not in my Ital. dictionary, is it local (Roman) slang?

    Enjoy your column very much. Thanks, Jim

    Reply
  3. Frank @Memorie di Angelina

    May 27, 2014 at 12:28 pm

    I love anchovies, but I’ve never though to pair them with potatoes for some odd reason. Now I’ve got a new way to enjoy them, thanks!

    I have to agree re: salt packed anchovies. I’ve read they’re superior to the oil packed variety, but I’ve never tasted enough difference to justify the fussiness involved in prepping them, especially when they’re going into a cooked dish with other ingredients. Then again, I’m lazy by nature…

    Reply
  4. robin

    June 16, 2014 at 12:49 am

    I made this and substituted purslane for arugula. It was very very good.

    Reply
    • Elizabeth

      June 16, 2014 at 5:13 am

      Purslane is a great idea. I love it’s crunch with potatoes.

      Reply

Leave a Reply (comments are moderated) Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

JOIN US FOR A WEEK IN ITALY

JOIN US FOR A WEEK IN ITALY

Buy my newest book

BUY MY BOOK
BUY MY BOOK

BUY SOPHIE'S BOOK

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Categories

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2025 Elizabeth Minchilli · Privacy Policy & FAQ

Elizabeth’s Newsletter from Italy

Sign up here for my newsletter! It’s full of fun information, travel tips, links to what I’m reading and doing, advance notice of my culinary tours, and reading events. Premium subscribers also have access to my new podcast, online events, and discounts and offers for some of my favorite tableware.

subscribe